Navigating the Cedar Tariff: Cost & Quality Considerations

The cedar tariff has been reinstated, and homeowners in New Jersey considering cedar for their roofing or siding projects are feeling the impact. The 25% tariff on Canadian lumber imports, following a brief suspension, has once again driven up prices, leaving many wondering if domestic cedar is a more affordable alternative. While cost is always a factor, understanding how the quality and durability of different cedar options impact long-term performance is just as important.

If you’re considering cedar roofing or siding, it’s essential to know how these tariffs affect pricing, how different types of cedar compare, and what to expect in terms of longevity and maintenance. Making an informed decision now can mean the difference between a long-lasting, low-maintenance investment and a project that requires frequent upkeep down the road.

Why Cedar? A Natural, Timeless Choice

Cedar has long been valued for its durability, natural resistance to rot and insects, and distinctive beauty. It’s an excellent material for siding and roofing because it holds up well in different weather conditions and can last for decades with proper care. Unlike synthetic alternatives, cedar also offers aesthetic warmth and character that enhances curb appeal.

However, not all cedar is the same. There are major differences between Canadian and domestic cedar, particularly when it comes to grain structure, moisture resistance, and overall stability. These differences impact how well the material performs over time—and with the cedar tariff making high-quality Canadian cedar more expensive, many homeowners are weighing their options.

Canadian Cedar: The Gold Standard

For years, Canadian Western Red Cedar has been the preferred choice for roofing and siding because of its superior strength, stability, and longevity. This cedar primarily comes from old-growth forests, which means the wood has a tight, vertical grain that makes it less prone to warping, twisting, or cupping.

Key Benefits of Canadian Cedar:

• Exceptional Dimensional Stability – The slow growth of old-growth trees produces wood with a dense, uniform grain, reducing movement over time.
• Kiln-Dried for Durability – Most Canadian cedar is kiln-dried, meaning excess moisture is removed before installation, minimizing shrinkage and cracking.
• Long-Lasting Beauty – With proper care, Canadian cedar maintains its rich color and structural integrity for decades.
• Less Maintenance – The stability of the wood means fewer issues over time, reducing the need for repairs.

While the cedar tariff has increased the cost of this premium material, the benefits it offers in terms of durability and maintenance savings often justify the investment.

Domestic Cedar: A Different Alternative

With Canadian cedar now more expensive, many homeowners are looking at domestic Western Red Cedar as an alternative. While it may come at a lower price point, there are important differences to consider.

Key Differences of Domestic Cedar:

• Wider, Less Stable Grain – Domestic cedar often comes from second-growth forests or even previously fallen trees, leading to a more inconsistent, looser grain that makes the wood more susceptible to warping and splitting.
• Higher Moisture Content – Domestic cedar is often sold green (not kiln-dried), meaning it retains more moisture. Over time, this can lead to shrinkage, cracking, and movement as the wood dries.
• Increased Maintenance – Because of its greater tendency to shift, domestic cedar may require more frequent maintenance to prevent issues like cupping or splitting.

While domestic cedar may be cheaper upfront, its shorter lifespan and higher maintenance costs should be considered when planning a long-term investment in roofing or siding.

How Different Cedar Varieties Compare

Beyond the Canadian vs. domestic debate, there are also different types of cedar, each with unique properties that impact performance.

1. Western Red Cedar (Canadian & Domestic) – The most common choice for siding and roofing. Canadian Western Red Cedar is denser and more stable, while domestic Western Red Cedar is more affordable but requires more upkeep.
2. Inland Red Cedar – A lighter, more uniform cedar that absorbs stains well but isn’t as durable as traditional Western Red Cedar.
3. Alaskan Yellow Cedar – A durable, weather-resistant wood that is highly rot-resistant but more expensive and less widely available.
4. Eastern White Cedar – Often used for shingles and fencing, this cedar has a lighter color and softer texture but doesn’t match the durability of Western Red Cedar.
5. Eastern Red Cedar – More commonly used for interior applications due to its aromatic properties, but not ideal for roofing or siding.

Knowing the strengths and weaknesses of different cedar varieties can help homeowners choose the best material for their needs, especially with the cedar tariff now in place.

The Long-Term Cost Factor

While the cedar tariff makes Canadian cedar more expensive at the outset, it’s important to consider the total cost of ownership.

• Higher Initial Investment, Lower Long-Term Costs – Canadian cedar’s superior quality means it lasts longer and requires fewer repairs, making it a cost-effective choice in the long run.
• Maintenance Matters – Domestic cedar, while cheaper upfront, often requires more frequent maintenance and potential replacements, which can add up over time.
• Value Over Time – A home with high-quality cedar siding or roofing maintains its beauty and structural integrity longer, adding to its overall resale value.

A lower price tag upfront doesn’t always mean long-term savings—choosing the right cedar ensures your investment holds up over time.

Making the Right Choice for Your Home

Cedar is a beautiful, durable material that adds character and longevity to any home. The cedar tariff has undoubtedly made high-quality Canadian cedar more expensive, but for homeowners who prioritize stability, durability, and reduced maintenance, it remains the best option.

For those looking for a more budget-friendly alternative, domestic cedar may be worth considering, but it’s essential to understand the trade-offs before making a final decision.

Trust a Professional for the Best Results

No matter which type of cedar you choose, proper installation and expert guidance are crucial. The right approach ensures that your cedar roofing or siding performs as expected and stands the test of time.

If you’re considering cedar for your home, Novalis Roofing & Siding can help you navigate the options and make the best choice for your budget and needs. With years of experience in New Jersey, we understand the unique challenges of the climate and how to install materials for long-lasting beauty and durability.

Contact Novalis Roofing & Siding today to discuss your cedar roofing or siding project and learn more about the best options available for your home.